Leadership plays a central role in enabling organizational change and long-term
sustainability. Although extensive research has examined leadership styles,
competencies, and behaviors, relatively little attention has been given to the
intrinsic values that shape leadership and influence sustainable organizational
outcomes across different institutional settings. Existing studies have generally
examined leadership within individual sectors, limiting understanding of whether
fundamental leadership values transcend organizational boundaries. Furthermore,
limited empirical evidence exists regarding whether such values can be
intentionally developed through structured leadership programs. This study
addresses these gaps by identifying the intrinsic leadership values that characterize
effective leadership across sectors, examining their relationships with
organizational change and organizational sustainability, and investigating the extent
to which these values can be cultivated through leadership development.
A sequential mixed-methods design was employed in three complementary phases.
The first phase consisted of a qualitative multiple-case study involving six
organizations representing the public, private, and nonprofit sectors. Data were
collected through 18 semi-structured interviews, focus group discussions, and
document analysis to identify recurring leadership values associated with successful
organizational change and sustainability. The second phase quantitatively examined
the relationships among Intrinsic Leadership Values (ILVs), Organizational Change
(OC), Sustaining Change (SC), and Organizational Sustainability (OS) using
Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). A total of 1,034 survey responses were
collected, of which 520 managerial respondents met the validation criteria and were
included in the final analysis. The third phase explored whether ILVs could be
intentionally strengthened through leadership development by analyzing survey and
focus group data from 139 alumni of structured leadership development programs.
The qualitative analysis identified five core Intrinsic Leadership Values that
consistently emerged across all six organizations despite differences in sector,
organizational purpose, and institutional context. These values are Trustworthy,
Courageous, Transformative, Visionary, and Collaborative. The consistency of these findings across public, private, and nonprofit organizations suggests that
effective leadership is grounded in a common set of intrinsic values rather than
being determined solely by sector-specific characteristics.
The quantitative findings provide empirical support for the proposed leadership
framework. Structural Equation Modeling indicates that Intrinsic Leadership
Values have significant positive relationships with both Organizational Change and
Organizational Sustainability. The analysis also identifies a reciprocal relationship
between Sustaining Change and Organizational Sustainability, suggesting that
sustaining change is not merely an outcome of successful transformation but also
reinforces an organization's long-term capacity to adapt, learn, and remain
sustainable. These findings position ILVs as foundational drivers of organizational
transformation and long-term institutional resilience across sectors.
The third phase further suggests that Intrinsic Leadership Values are not fixed
personal attributes but can be intentionally strengthened through structured
leadership development. Participants consistently reported that reflective learning,
experiential activities, mentoring, and cross-sector engagement contributed to
stronger alignment between personal values and leadership practice. Although these
findings are based on participants' self-reported experiences, they indicate that
leadership values can be reinforced through well-designed developmental
interventions rather than relying solely on individual disposition.
This study contributes to leadership theory by developing and empirically
examining a cross-sector framework of Intrinsic Leadership Values that integrates
leadership, organizational change, and organizational sustainability within a single
relational model. It extends the literature by demonstrating that values-based
leadership provides a common foundation for effective leadership across public,
private, and nonprofit organizations while offering empirical evidence that these
values can be intentionally developed. The findings also provide practical
implications for organizations seeking to strengthen leadership capacity by
emphasizing the development of intrinsic values alongside technical and
managerial competencies. The proposed framework offers a foundation for future
research on values-based leadership and provides guidance for designing leadership
development initiatives that support sustainable organizational transformation
across diverse institutional contexts.
Keywords: Intrinsic Leadership Values, organizational change, organizational
sustainability, values-based leadership, cross-sector leadership, leadership
development, structural equation modeling.
Perpustakaan Digital ITB