The major problem's research in this report is the need for achieving the desired
business performance by focusing on optimal costs through engineering IT
resources. This is needed in view of the existing methodology does not consider the
causal relationship between the superior performance and the optimal cost, yet
current approaches have concerned to analyze the relationship between IT resource
and firm performance. Essentially, this study is continuing the previous researchers
confirming that there has been a positive IT’s role to bring a business up in
performance. Nevertheless, this study does the different paradigm of the previous
studies, namely, it configures its research block diagram in a combination of series
and parallel or hybrid to engineer the resources in accomplishing the IT value. This
construction refers to an IT value engineering concept, which recommends a
systems engineering methodology associated with IT inclusion in an organization
to create a superior performance at optimal costs.
Consequently, to solve the problem, a number of propositions direct the research as
follows: 1) the procedure for testing the IT value model can be developed to verify
and validate the model, so it is reliable as a basic concept to solve the problem of
this research; 2) the model structure consists of several subsystems, namely IT
resources, firm capability, firm core competence, and firm performance in a hybrid
configuration; 3) the relationship between the subsystems on the structure of the
resulting model can be reorganized in order to facilitate the compliance of the
desired performance criteria and optimize the cost; 4) it is able to optimize the
ITVEF in minimizing costs or maximizing revenues; and 5) the framework should
be internally and externally stable. For that understanding, the applied research
design is using systems engineering through an engineering design process by
defining the problem, generating alternative solutions, selecting a solution,
detailing the aim, and validating the model. Additionally, this methodology works
together with the meta-analysis approach to help analyze the correlation between
IT resources and performance. Likewise, another tool is the Partial Adjustment
Valuation (PAV) theory that helps to be as a valuation method between the desired
output (input) and the realized output of each subsystem (output). This is running
for both dynamic and static speeds of adjustment of PAV. Moreover, the eight IT-based firms’ data, namely Telkom, Indosat, XL, BTEL,
Smartfren, Mandiri, BRI, and BNI function to examine the model. The experiment
and validation outcomes exhibit that the model has shaped as desired although
several anomalies have appeared. Nonetheless, the experiment and further studies
have already resolved the above propositions where the IT value model procedure
facilitates to disclose that IT values are real; the IT value model contains four
subsystems: IT resources, firm capability, firm core competence, and firm
performance, in which their relationship is in a hybrid configuration; the
relationship among the subsystems is positively reorganized with considering IT
business ecosystem to realize the desired performance criteria and optimize the
cost; the ITVEF is an optimal framework; and the framework is internally and
externally stable.
Subsequently, the study results release a hybrid fashion model that is structuring
the IT resource, the firm capability, the firm core competence, and the firm
performance in a hybrid configuration to construct an IT value engineering
framework (ITVEF). The framework carries out an engineering process
methodology, whereas the input is the desired output (y*
t) exemplified by the Cobb-
Douglas production function. In addition, this production function input consists of
regular capital (K), labor expense (L) and IT spending (I) that spread among four
subsystems above. Meanwhile, the output of the framework is the firm’s gross
operating revenue (yt).
Additionally, this research contributes to scientific developments from several
perspectives, namely 1) the IT value assessment has been carried out among the
subsystems; 2) the research generates a passion in IT value study due to
interdisciplinary of fields (systems engineering, meta-analysis, and PAV), whereas
it did not happen before in IT value research; 3) a novel approach to capital
allocation by the hybrid configuration, whereas its allocation considers many
system’s variables and indicators; 4) this research also launches a novel term: IT
value engineering in studying the IT values; 5) this study resulted in the ITVEF,
which is not only to remodel the patterns of the IT value study but also to result in
the concrete estimation of the IT spending and the firm performance in their units,
and 6) this research has applied two types of speed of adjustment, which is a
coefficient between the change in real output of a production process and the
desired output alteration. Nevertheless, there are several weaknesses found in this
research, such as revenue separation between the model with IT inclusion and
without it; therefore, it needs to do future studies to complete the research.