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ÖáU Ö 6HKLQJJDVHFDUDPDWHPDWLVV\DUDWEDWDVVLVWHPLQLGDSDWGLWXOLVNDQVHEDJDL :TF4; 6 E:UF4; 6 L4 6 GDQà 4EàL 6 ,9 GDQV\DUDWDZDOVLVWHPLQLDGDODKEHQGDGLOXQFXUNDQWDQSDNHFHSDWDQDZDOVHFDUD PDWHPDWLVGLWXOLVNDQVHEDJDLEHULNXW R:TáUár;Lr ,9 *DPEDU,9PHQGHVNULSVLNDQEDKZDVXGXWà 4PHUXSDNDQVXGXWDZDOEHQGDVDDW DNDQPHOXQFXUSDGDELGDQJVHSHUHPSDWOLQJNDUDQWHUKDGDSVXPEX[6DDWEHQGD DNDQGLOXQFXUNDQ WDQSDNHFHSDWDQDZDO SDGDNHWLQJJLDQKPDNDEHVDUVXGXWà 4 SHUOXGLNHWDKXL.DUHQDVXGXWà 4KDQ\DGLJXQDNDQXQWXNPHQHQWXNDQNHWLQJJLDQ EHQGDVDDWGLOXQFXUNDQPDNDVHFDUDPDWHPDWLVGLSHUROHKKXEXQJDQEHULNXW 4LDE4•‹�à 4 DL4F4•‹�à 4 DL4:sF•‹�à 4; ,9 DGDSXQXQWXNPHQJHWDKXLEHVDUVXGXWà 4DNLEDWNHWLQJJLDQKGDSDWGLOLKDWSDGD SHUVDPDDQ ,9 à 4L•‹� . 5 @s F Û Ë A ,9 VHGDQJNDQ EHVDU VXGXWà PHUXSDNDQ VXGXW \DQJ PHQJDODPL SHUXEDKDQ GDQ PHPLOLNLSHQJDUXKWHUKDGDSJHUDNEHQGDGHQJDQJHVHNDQNHWLNDPHOXQFXUSDGD OLQWDVDQ VHSHUHPSDW OLQJNDUDQ 6HKLQJJD GDSDW GLDUWLNDQ EDKZD JHUDN EHQGD PHOXQFXUEHUJDQWXQJ DWDXWHULNDW WHUKDGDS EHVDU VXGXWà 4GDQVXGXWà$GDSXQ GDODPELGDQJNDMLDQNLQHPDWLNDSRVLVLJHUDNEHQGDSDGDVXPEX[GDQVXPEX\ WHUKDGDSVXGXWà 4GDQVXGXWàGLWXOLVNDQGDODPSHUVDPDDQ ,9 GDQSHUVDPDDQ ,9 EHULNXW TL4F4…‘•:à 4Eà; TL4:sF…‘•:à 4Eà;; ,9 GDQ UL4:sF•‹�:à 4Eà;; ,9 +XNXP,,1HZWRQPHQMHODVNDQJHUDNEHQGDGDSDWGLWLQMDXSDGDDUDKUDGLDOPDXSXQ WDQJHQVLDO-LNDPHQLQMDXNRPSRQHQDUDKUDGLDOJHUDNEHQGDPDNDGLSHUROHK Ã(LI= p _ b ,9 %HUGDVDUNDQ SHUVDPDDQ ,, GDQ JD\DJD\D \DQJ EHNHUMD SDGD DUDK UDGLDO SHUVDPDDQ ,9 GDSDWGLXUDLNDQVHEDJDLEHULNXW 0FS•‹�:à 4Eà;LI R:à; 6 4 0LS•‹�:à 4Eà;EI R:à; 6 4 GLSHUROHKSHUVDPDDQJD\DQRUPDOEHQGDVHSHUWL\DQJGLWXQMXNNDQSHUVDPDDQ ,9 EHULNXW 0LIC•‹�:à 4Eà;EI é: ; . Ë ,9 GDQMLNDPHQLQMDXNRPSRQHQDUDKWDQJHQVLDOJHUDNEHQGDPDND Ã(LI= r _ l ,9 %HUGDVDUNDQSHUVDPDDQ ,, GDQJD\DJD\D\DQJEHNHUMDSDGDDUDKWDQJHQVLDO SHUVDPDDQ ,9 GDSDWGLXUDLNDQSDGDSHUVDPDDQ ,9 S…‘•:à 4Eà;FB ÚLI @R @P IC …‘•:à 4Eà;Fä Þ0LI × é × ç ,9 GHQJDQ PHODNXNDQ VXEWLWXVL SHUVDPDDQ ,9 NH SHUVDPDDQ ,9 PDND GLSHUROHKSHUVDPDDQ ,9 IC …‘•:à 4Eà;Fä ÞDIC •‹�:à 4Eà;EI é: ; . Ë ELI × é × ç ,9 SHUVDPDDQ ,9 UHNXUVLIGHQJDQ 4 × é × ç Eä ÞR:à; 6 LC4